Classic flavors and inventive creations such as bourbon-sweet potato spring up at this destination-worthy shop in the up-and-coming Gowanus neighborhood.
Top 10 Best Places for P...
by Bon Appetit
Those who can resist the siren call of a perfectly baked pie are stronger souls than we. (Do such people even exist?) Made with seasonal fruit filling, secret techniques, and crust recipes passed down through generations, today's pies really do take the cake. By Andrew Knowlton
Your progress on this list (you can make more progress by trying out restaurants on this list!)
Can't get your location :( change
Sort by:
Only show places...
Cuisine
Neighborhoods
Price
2 The Apple Pan $ Hamburgers, Bakery, Dessert / Ice Cream
10801 W Pico Blvd, Los Angeles, CAThis Westside institution (open since 1947) is better known for its burgers, both the Steakburger and the Hickoryburger, but don't overlook the fresh-baked pies—available in apple, cream, and pecan—best ordered à la mode.
3 Hoosier Mama Pie Company $ Bakery, Dessert / Ice Cream
1618 1/2 Chicago Ave., Chicago, ILAt this retro-styled spot in Ukrainian Village, the menu from pastry chef Paula Haney includes five types of chess pie, as well as other American regional favorites like Indiana's famous sugar cream.
4 Petsi Pies $ Bakery, Dessert / Ice Cream
285 Beacon St., Somerville, MAJust outside Boston, Renee McLeod serves the city's best sweet potato pie and southern pecan pie. Special flavors such as banana-chocolate cream must be ordered 48 hours ahead.
5 Paris Coffee Shop $ Bakery, Dessert / Ice Cream
700 W Magnolia Ave., Fort Worth, TXLike big meringue pie slices in flavors such as coconut and chocolate? Want to sit in a diner-like setting? Yearn for super-friendly owners? This is the place of your dreams.
6 Scratch Baking $ Bakery, Dessert / Ice Cream
111 Orange St., Durham, NCDurham Farmers' Market alum Phoebe Lawless now sells sweet (chocolate-sea salt) and savory (beet green and guanciale) pies at her 18-seat spot downtown.
7 Pie Lab $ Bakery, Dessert / Ice Cream
1317 Main St. , Greensboro, ALThe motto of this spot—part pie shop, part design studio, part community center—is "Pie + Conversation = Ideas." We guarantee the apple pies are made with great ingredients and passion—prerequisites of all the best pies.
8 Achatz Handmade Pie Co $ Dessert / Ice Cream, Bakery
75700 North Ave., Armada, MIJudges at the National Pie Championships awarded the cherry and Michigan Four Berry pies here top honors. And in Chicago, Alinea chef Grant Achatz serves pies from this outfit (run by his second cousin Dave and Dave's wife, Wendy) at staff meals.
9 Lancaster Central Market $ Bakery, Dessert / Ice Cream
23 N Market St., Lancaster, PAAt this long-running indoor farmers' market, several of the stands sell shoofly pie (at its core, a mixture of molasses, sugar, and butter) and other outstanding flavors.
10 Fuel Coffee $ Coffeehouse, Bakery, Dessert / Ice Cream
610 19th Ave. E, Seattle, WAHead to Fuel Coffee for baker Dani Cone's classic pies as well as mini Cutie Pies, Flipsides (kind of like turnovers), and Piejars (baked in mini mason jars) in flavors like spiced plum walnut.